I ALSO read this series back in the day and I rec it all the time! I resisted rereading for a while (for the same reasons--couldn't face if it wasn't the way I remmebered) but I gave in not too long ago, and it was a blast! Jack's motorcycle! Mike's long runs! The place it fell apart for me was when it was revealed that Mike once had a thing with Ben Stone--that was where I was all, OH NOES, STOP. But Logan/McCoy worked for me where it totally shouldn'tve. I sent her ridiculously happy feedback!